A delicious crispy crust pizza is a family favorite, enjoyed by everyone from children to the elderly. Thus, the reason that every household is hooked to baking pizza at home. Making pizza from scratch takes time and effort, the right equipment, the right ingredients, and even the right attitude. But you don’t want to end up with a mess when making pizza at home. That’s why I’ve put together a list of the best pizza pans you can use to bake the perfect pizza.
Comparison Chart
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan | The best pan for homemade pizza is the Lodge Cast Iron Pan that comes with loop handles. | ||
| Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan | Home-Complete feature a 14 inches pizza pan skillet that you can use for cooking, baking classic pizza flavor. | ||
| Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Pizza Pan | Today’s cooks prefer the Chef’s Classics nonstick bakeware because of its affordability and durability. | ||
| Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone | Baking crispy pizza is easy using this cast iron pizza pan. Know more about this pan and find out why it gives a better deal for you. | ||
| Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan | Chicago Metallic deep dish pizza pan helps you bake the best Chicago-style deep dish pizza pan. | ||
| G&S Metal Products Company ProBake Non-Stick Teflon Xtra Pizza Baking Pan | G&S Metal Products Company ProBake Non-Stick Teflon Xtra Pizza Baking Pan will help you make crispy and tasty pizza for your family. | ||
| New Star Foodservice 50752 Pizza Pan | New Star Pizza Tray is another 14-inch pizza pan that could quite quickly help you cook up a giant pizza. |
Detailed Reviews of the 7 Best Pizza Pans
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan
The best pan for homemade pizza is the Lodge Cast Iron Pan that comes with loop handles.
Product Highlights
The Lodge 14 Inch Cast Iron Baking Pan is the best option for homemade pizza, baked treats, or roasted vegetables with its large baking surface and strong handles. For efficient, even cooking, it provides excellent heat transfer and retention, and the side handles allow a smooth, secure grip. In the oven, stove, or grill and over a campfire, you can use this baking pan easily. The cookware will cook pizza in 4 minutes at a medium heat of 400 degrees Fahrenheit.
The Good
It has two side handles, which means that you can shield it from the sun comfortably. Without cracking and the need to patch it, it will last a lifetime, makes the Lodge pizza pan a useful tool that won’t let you down, thanks to the robust pan material and exterior. The cast iron content in which the pan is manufactured gives the product a tremendous amount of durability. The pan also offers excellent heat retention, enabling all your pizzas to be cooked evenly.
The Bad
One major drawback when washing the pan, you have to be patient because you can only wash it by hand to make sure you don’t hurt it.
PROs
- Heavy-duty cast iron baking pan
- Comes with sturdy two loop handles
- Excellent heat retention
- Perfect for 14-inch pizzas and baked goodies
CONs
- Hand wash only
- Some individuals say the pan is a bit small
- A little expensive
Home-Complete Cast Iron Pizza Pan
Home-Complete feature a 14 inches pizza pan skillet that you can use for cooking, baking classic pizza flavor.
Product Highlights
The home-complete iron pizza pan skillet features cast iron, and versatile use of the durable material is known. This pan is not only for grilling crispy crust pizza, but also for grilling vegetables and meats, roasting, and frying. Also, you can use it every day to cook eggs, bacon, burgers, pancakes. This cast iron pan is good at retaining heat, making baking faster and more effective. It also results in your pizzas becoming even and crispy crust.
The Good
Other ways of cooking and baking that may be of interest to those who enjoy experimenting in the kitchen may also use the skillet. For instance, in this pan, you can broil, fry, and bake any meat and vegetables. The pan is perfect for baking cookies, crepes, and fries, due to much heat in the middle of the pan when used, and the outer edges are cooler.
The Bad
The base coating is a little rough on the market than other cast iron pans, so cleaning after use takes time.
PROs
- Perfect for baking, roasting, and grilling
- Saves cooking time and energy
- Safe to use
- Comes with convenient handles
CONs
- You have to oil it to prevent rust
- A bit heavy
- Rough exterior
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Pizza Pan
Today’s cooks prefer the Chef’s Classics nonstick bakeware because of its affordability and durability.
Product Highlights
This pizza pan has a pierce surface to guarantee that each pizza you bake has an exquisitely crispy crust and smooth rolled edges to prevent your pizza from warping. This nonstick pizza pan comes with strong gauge aluminized steel to provide uniform heating and consistent baking outcomes. The nonstick’s interior and exterior ensure easy release and food cleanup and prevent cracking of the extra-thick rolling edges. This pizza pan is dishwasher safe.
The Good
The pan also has a nonstick inside and outside, making the repair process quick and less time-consuming than other panes. The nonstick interior will also help ease the release of the food before it is over. For the dishwasher, this pan is secure, making washing easy and straightforward.
The Bad
The holes are annoying if you use a pan, so you can get all kinds of crumbs into them when you cut the pie. In between the holes, the stuff gets caught.
PROs
- Comes with nonstick interior and exterior plate
- Features perforated surface
- Heavy-gauge aluminized steel
- Warp resistant
CONs
- Does not come with handles
- A little heavy
- Durability is a concern
Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone
Baking crispy pizza is easy using this cast iron pizza pan. Know more about this pan and find out why it gives a better deal for you.
Product Highlights
This pan will make sure that any pizza you cook is cooked evenly once again. Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone is designed to use in the oven or on a BBQ grill. It is also safe to use on charcoal, gas, and natural wood grills up to 900 degrees Fahrenheit. This pan is safe for dishwashing, which makes the process of cleaning very quick.
The Good
In terms of baking a pizza at home, its nonstick surface makes the pan a convenient and easy option. You can put the pan in the oven and let it cook for you all the time. It comes with handles so you can carry it with ease, especially when it is warm. It can be used in all types of ovens and even under the broiler.
The Bad
One major drawback about this pizza pan is, it cannot withstand too hot temperature and can break in half.
PROs
- Durable and rust-free
- Easy to clean
- You can cook up to 900 degrees Fahrenheit
- Comes with handles
CONs
- Suitable for thin crust pizza only
- Only the middle part of the food cooks faster
- It easy breaks into half
Chicago Metallic Deep Dish Pizza Pan
Chicago Metallic deep dish pizza pan helps you bake the best Chicago-style deep dish pizza pan.
Product Highlights
For immense strength and longevity, the pan is heavy-duty carbon steel. It is 14 inches wide and 1.5 inches high, making it a perfect instrument for other dishes/desserts that are deep and dense. For improved heat distribution and quick washing, it has a high-quality, nonstick coating. When you want to bake your deep-dish pizza at home, this pan is a great choice. As it is silicone-based, it comes with a fast release surface to ensure your deep-dish pizza does not stick to the pan.
The Good
This pan is for you, the high edge pizza, and the ability to keep a huge amount of cheese and tomato inside like pizza Chicago-style. In your oven, it’s perfect for making deep-dish pizza, cookie pie, or stuffed pizza at home. It also helps clean the pan as you would not have burnt pizza bits stuck to your pan that seem hard to scrape off. You can clean this pan using a dishwasher.
The Bad
What we don’t like about this pizza pan is it’s not scratch resistant. Some users mentioned not to use sharp objects as it could scratch the pan.
PROs
- Dishwasher safe
- Easy to use
- It is lightweight
- No warping under high heat
CONs
- This pan has no handles
- Durability is a concern
- May not be ideal for frying eggs, and veggies
G&S Metal Products Company ProBake Non-Stick Teflon Xtra Pizza Baking Pan
G&S Metal Products Company ProBake Non-Stick Teflon Xtra Pizza Baking Pan will help you make crispy and tasty pizza for your family.
Product Highlights
This pizza pan is made of Teflon Xtra nonstick finish for high performance which makes it an ideal pan to withstand high heat. It has a superior release coating so you don’t need to use grease or cooking sprays.
- MAKE THE BEST PIZZA YET: Whether it’s frozen, fresh or reheated from last night’s dinner, bake a perfect pizza every time thanks to ProBake Set of Two Nonstick 16-inch Pizza Pans.
- HIGH PERFORMANCE: ProBake bakeware is coated with a Teflon Xtra nonstick finish designed for high performance, making this an ideal pan to withstand the wear and tear of everyday use.
- SUPERIOR RELEASE COATING: No need for grease or cooking sprays. Even the cheesiest of pizzas won’t stick making cleanup quick and easy.
- DURABLE STEEL CONSTRUCTION: Pan is made with professional weight steel construction ensuring even heating with no hot spots for perfect pizza crust.
- QUALITY ASSURANCE: The ProBake Set of Two Nonstick 16-inch Pizza Pan is made in the USA, made without PFOA, and is backed by a 10-year limited warranty.
The Good
This pan is made with steel construction to ensure even heating without hot spots for perfect pizza crust. Even the cheese of pizza won’t stick on the pan which will make your clean up quick and easy. This pan is also light and it slides off easily and makes your pizza crust nice, brown, and crispy.
The Bad
Some users complained these pans are easily getting rust and it is quite flimsy. It also doesn’t have handles that are hard to use.
PROs
- Heavy-gauge steel
- Perfect for single-serve pizza
- Easy to clean
- Comes with four different sizes of pan
CONs
- These pans do not have handles
- It is flimsy and it rusts easily
- Durability is an issue
New Star Foodservice 50752 Pizza Pan
New Star Pizza Tray is another 14-inch pizza pan that could quite quickly help you cook up a giant pizza.
Product Highlights
It is made of industrial-quality aluminum and comes with no coating that flakes off. When used in the dishwasher, this pan will kill bacteria, so make sure to wash by hand with warm water and soap. With thick hardware and reinforced braces, the New Star pizza tray boasts durable, water-resistant, high-duty nylon. By removing rough or twisted edges, you can be sure of improved handling and washing, since it is smooth.
The Good
The pan has slightly sloped sides to ensure that your toppings do not overflow into the oven and instead transform into a perfect crust. For those that don’t want them, you can use this pizza pan to avoid crusts or add some extra crust for those who want it. Pizza trays are a common pizza pan choice that can help to simplify your pizza operation.
The Bad
Some customers say they wash the pan with a sponge, and it marks it shouldn’t happen. It is also a bit flimsy and tends to bend easily.
PROs
- Comes with various sizes
- Features sloped edges
- Made of food-safe aluminum
- Perfect for baking pizza and other foods
CONs
- Hand wash only
- A bit flimsy
- Tends to bend easily
Conclusion
The best pizza pan is important to ensure that you produce the best-tasting pizza that can leave your tummy feeling satisfied. We hope this article has given you some insight into the various pizza pans styles out there and has taught you what to look for when you pick your pizza pan. Find out more about pizza pans.