Who is not a fan of pizza? It’s a family’s favorite, enjoyed by everybody at any time of the day. With the variety of flavors and toppings ready, it is no surprise that pizza is so easy to access. If you love baking pizza, then it’s time you buy the best pizza tray. We’ve compiled a list of pizza pans and trays in this roundup to help you pick the right one for you. We’ve also included the best features, so you won’t find yourself buying an item that you wish you never did.
Comparison Chart
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nordic Ware Natural Bakeware Aluminum 14 in. Thin Crust Pizza Pan | Its impressive features made Nordic Pizza Tray stand out as one of today’s best baking pans on the market. | ||
| Good Cook Nonstick Pizza Tray | Bake pizza with this Good Cook nonstick bakeware. | ||
| OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Tray Pan | The heavy-duty design of this bakeware package meets kitchen, oven roasting, and toasting specifications. | ||
| Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware Set | These cookie pans have strong gauge steel that can withstand warping to keep your food cooked, roasted, and toasted. | ||
| New Star Foodservice 50752 Pizza Pan/Tray | New Star Pizza Tray is another 14-inch pizza pan that could quite quickly help you cook up a giant pizza. | ||
| Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Pizza Pan | Today’s cooks prefer the Chef’s Classics nonstick bakeware because of its affordability and durability. | ||
| Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan | The best pan for homemade pizza is the Lodge Cast Iron Pan that comes with loop handles. |
Detailed Reviews of the 7 Best Pizza Trays
Nordic Ware Natural Bakeware Aluminum 14 in. Thin Crust Pizza Pan
Its impressive features made Nordic Ware Natural Bakeware Aluminum 14 in. Thin Crust Pizza Pan stands out as one of today’s best baking pans on the market.
Product Highlights
The half sheet of Nordicware baker is a two-piece baking sheet made from tough, pure aluminum for flawless baking. This best pizza tray’s rust-free properties give you justification for owning one and enjoying your food without contamination. A galvanized steel rim with strengthened wire construction offers exceptional stability to the pan for warp-free baking. It’s quick to get the pan in and out of your oven. Thanks to its bulky edges that provide enough room and safe grip. With this saucepan, you can conveniently bake, roast, steam, and toast.
The Good
Nordic Ware makes it simple to bake pizza. Even if the pan is full, you can rest assured that you can get a good grip on the side. The tray has the same size and is pure aluminum. This material delivers excellent heat conductivity, so your food cooks incredibly fast.
The Bad
The Half Sheet by Nordic Ware Natural Bakeware Aluminum 14 in. Thin Crust Pizza Pan is not durable. It appears to dent and bend, especially when placed in the dishwasher. The Half Sheet by Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Tray is not durable. It appears to dent and bend, especially when placed in the dishwasher.
PROs
- Rust-resistant design
- Made of aluminum
- Even heat distribution
- Lightweight and versatile
- Comes with oversized edges
CONs
- Not dishwasher safe
- Tends to bend easily
- May not be durable enough
Good Cook Nonstick Pizza Tray
Bake pizza with this Good Cook nonstick bakeware.
Product Highlights
The kit comes as a three-piece set consisting of a baking sheet big, medium, and small. Every piece comes with a high-quality nonstick coating that allows the preparation of greasy foods without staining. The surface also helps you to quickly release your food while avoiding staining and the need for scrubbing. Each tray in the package is completely safe in the dishwasher. That means you can make them particularly easy to clean.
The Good
Each of these special baking pans is slightly different in size. Good Cook includes three sets, which makes the selection of the tray you need incredibly easy. You’ll be enjoying years of perfect baking with this set piece. There’s no reason you should stop treating your loved ones with their favorite pizza.
The Bad
A dishwasher finds rusty water from these pans at the bottom of the dishwasher. Out of the crimped edges comes the rust.
PROs
- Lifetime warranty
- Comes with three nonstick pizza tray
- Dishwasher safe
- Easy to use and maintain
CONs
- Might be prone to rust
- Nonstick coating removes easily after some uses
- Durability is an issue
OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Tray Pan
The heavy-duty design of this bakeware package meets kitchen, oven roasting, and toasting specifications.
Product Highlights
The bakeware features aluminized steel of industrial quality for high performance. Also reinforced with a two-layer ceramic coating for improved strength, fast release of food without rubbing, staining, or corroding. Its nonstick surface is finely contoured to minimize contact with the surface and encourages fast airflow for flawless baking. Adding consistency to this bakeware is its square, rounded edges, which provide a tight fit for a smooth transfer of food inside and outside your oven.
The Good
This baking pan is comfortable and safe to handle, just like the other top models in the OXO Good Grips. It is sturdy with a tall and thick lip. It ensures you’ll be able to take it out of the oven with ease, even though the tray is full of food. OXO pizza tray helps to ensure a quick flow of air each time for perfect baking.
The Bad
This sheet pan is a decent choice, but it comes at a slightly higher price, and it doesn’t come with a guarantee to cover it.
PROs
- Stain and scratch-resistant
- Top-grade aluminum coating
- Bakes pizza evenly
- Lightweight and easy to use
CONs
- Tends to warp easily
- The pan does not come with a warranty
- Not dishwasher safe
Rachael Ray Nonstick Bakeware Set
These cookie pans have strong gauge steel that can withstand warping to keep your food cooked, roasted, and toasted.
Product Highlights
Crafted with a heavily anodized steel frame, it is suitable for baking up to 500 degrees F. Practical silicone grip handles help to quickly position and shift the oven. The product comes with three different shapes and sizes of high-edge pans, and all the pans are wrapped in a nonstick coating that is suitable for ranges up to 500 degrees. The pans are made of high-pressure steel and are not going to warp over time. The pans are ideal for the dishwasher.
The Good
Long-lasting nonstick cookie plates offer excellent food extraction when baking, roasting, and so on and have a quick cleanup. The pan is 18 by 11.5 inches with handles; it’s a little larger than regular pizza tray and pans in the kitchen. This package is a number, but for a great price, you get three pans.
The Bad
The warping seems to rely on when cooled. When hot, this pizza tray does not work well, and sometimes produces uneven baking. This nonstick bakeware also makes it more likely to spill over into the oven.
PROs
- Consists of three different pan sizes
- Comes with nonstick coating and high rimmed edges
- Features silicone handles
- Extra surface depth
CONs
- The pan stains easily
- The pan tends to peel and cracks after a few uses
- Does not come with a warranty
New Star Foodservice 50752 Pizza Pan/Tray
New Star Pizza Tray is another 14-inch pizza pan that could quite quickly help you cook up a giant pizza.
Product Highlights
It is made of aluminum of industrial quality and comes with no coating that flakes off. This pan will oxidize when used in the dishwasher, so be sure to wash with warm water and soap by hand. New Star pizza tray boasts tough, water-resistant, high-duty nylon with thick stitching and reinforced braces. You can be sure of better handling and cleaning by removing rough or bent edges because it is smooth.
The Good
The pan has slightly sloped sides to ensure that your toppings don’t overflow over into the oven and turn into a perfect crust instead. You can use this pizza pan to remove crusts for those who don’t want them or add some extra crust for those who like it. Pizza trays are a popular pizza pan option and can help simplify the process of your pizza.
The Bad
Some customers say they wash the pan with a sponge, and it marks it shouldn’t happen. It is also a bit flimsy and tends to bend easily.
PROs
- Comes with various sizes
- Features sloped edges
- Made of food-safe aluminum
- Perfect for baking pizza and other foods
CONs
- Hand wash only
- A bit flimsy
- Tends to bend easily
Cuisinart Chef’s Classic Nonstick Pizza Pan
Today’s cooks prefer the Chef’s Classics nonstick bakeware because of its affordability and durability.
Product Highlights
This pizza pan has a pierce surface to ensure that there are an exquisitely crispy crust and smooth rolled edges in each pizza you bake to prevent your pizza from warping. The complete line features strong gauge aluminized steel to provide even heat distribution and reliable baking results. The interior and exterior of the nonstick ensure quick release and cleanup of food, and the extra-thick rolling edges avoid warping. The whole line is secure for the dishwasher. Whatever the baking job, Cuisinart quality promises you excellent performance for life.
The Good
The pan also has an interior and exterior nonstick, which makes the maintenance process simple and less time-consuming than other panes. The interior of the nonstick will also help to ease the release of the food until finished. This pan is safe for the dishwasher, making washing comfortable and straightforward.
The Bad
If you use a pan, the holes are irritating because when you cut the pie, you can get all sorts of crumbs through them. The stuff gets caught in between the gap.
PROs
- Comes with nonstick interior and exterior plate
- Features perforated surface
- Heavy-gauge aluminized steel
- Warp resistant
CONs
- Does not come with handles
- A little heavy
- Durability is a concern
Lodge Cast Iron Baking Pan
The best pan for homemade pizza is the Lodge Cast Iron Pan that comes with loop handles.
Product Highlights
The large baking surface and sturdy handles make the Lodge 14 Inch Cast Iron Baking Pan the ideal choice for homemade pizza, baked goodies, or roasted vegetables. It delivers excellent heat transfer and retention for reliable, even cooking, and the side handles allow smooth, secure grip. You can safely use this baking pan in the oven, stove or grill, and over a campfire. The cookware at medium heat 400 degrees Fahrenheit can cook pizza in 4 minutes.
The Good
This best pizza tray has two side handles, which make sure you can comfortably protect it from the sun. It will last a lifetime without cracking and the need to repair it, making the Lodge pizza pan an investment that won’t let you down, thanks to the durable material and exterior of the pan. The cast iron content in which the pan is made gives the product an enormous amount of durability. The pan also provides excellent heat retention, allowing for even cooking of all your pizzas.
The Bad
However, when washing the pan, you have to be patient, because you can only wash it by hand to make sure you don’t hurt it.
PROs
- Heavy-duty cast iron baking pan
- Comes with sturdy two loop handles
- Excellent heat retention
- Perfect for 14-inch pizzas and baked goodies
CONs
- Hand wash only
- Some individuals say the pan is a bit small
- A little expensive
Conclusion
The best pizza tray is critical to make sure you have the best-tasting pizza that can make your tummy feel good. This article gave you some insight into the various types of pizza pans out there and enlightened you about what to look for when picking yourself a pizza tray. Know more about pizza trays.